• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

  • ABOUT
  • SERVICES
    • COPY & FEATURE WRITING
    • DESIGN & BRANDING
    • ONLINE MARKETING
  • PORTFOLIO
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Shame, Shame, Logo Garden

August 29, 2011

Shutterstock image

The Logo Garden affair is the buzz going around these days.

It’s not a good buzz.

Logo Garden, in its effort to offer “do-it-yourself logos for entrepreneurs,” has apparently copied work created by other designers. It then resells it without the designers’ permission, all for its own profit. And because Logo Garden is a logo warehouse, meaning it resells each icon over and over, it’s reselling these stolen logos to multiples of unsuspecting consumers who think they’re getting a great deal for only $79.

Of course, designers are upset. Big name logo designers like Rock Paper Ink, Prejean Creative and Jeff Fisher LogoMotives have had thousands of logos stolen and they’re taking legal action against Logo Garden owner John Williams. AIGA (formerly an acronym for the American Institute of Graphic Arts), has posted action alerts and other helpful advice for designers here and here.

But what about consumers? Shouldn’t they be upset as well?

You bet they should and here’s why.

When an entrepreneur hires a professional to design his logo, he’s paying for a unique representation of his business. The designer can only do this through extensive interview, research and creative process, all of which the entrepreneur wisely pays for. But not only is he paying for this service, he’s also buying ownership rights to the logo—solely and completely, as his own personal icon. A logo is intellectual property and copyright laws protect this ownership.

When an entrepreneur brands his company, acquiring a logo is only one part of the process. The entrepreneur must then promote that logo and secure it in the minds of his market. He must build a reputation that positively associates the logo to his business. This is branding and it takes great time and effort.

So what happens when a schmuck like John Williams and his Logo Garden comes along?

When Williams steals a designer’s logo, he’s also stealing the intellectual property of the entrepreneur who hired that designer. And when Williams resells that stolen logo, he’s completely destroying the branding work the entrepreneur did to market his business.

Then there’s the unknowing consumer who purchases one of these 10,000 logos supposedly created by John Williams and “his hand-picked team of world-class logo designers.” (Be real, how could anyone and his team create 10,000 original, well-thought and designed logos?)

I’m going to credit these $79 tightwad consumers and say they were unknowing of Logo Garden’s unethical behavior. I’m also going to say they’re unknowing of successful marketing. Obviously, none of them believes their business qualifies for a professional, unique identity.

Anyway, these Logo Garden consumers are possibly setting themselves up for legal action. The great bargain they thought they were getting could very well be the intellectual property of another owner. They may find themselves forced to give it up. Suddenly, that $79 is not such a bargain after all.

Here’s something to think about:

If you’re a professional, you have to look professional. If you have a quality product, you must have a quality look.

Beware of logo warehouses. Don’t shop at Logo Garden.

Shame on you, Logo Garden!

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: copyright, ethics, giving it some thought, graphic design, logos, marketing  
8 Comments

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. john williams says

    August 29, 2011 at 12:16 pm

    About a week ago, design professionals alerted us that some symbols in LogoGarden.com’s vast symbol library were copies of existing work. On LogoGarden’s Facebook page and other social channels, we immediately responded, saying we would remove any offending symbols as they were spotted. In days that followed, we did so and let the design community know. We ourselves found other apparent duplicates and removed them. I wish to thank the design professionals who helped us identify offending symbols.

    Meanwhile, a few professional designers came to believe that systematic copying of existing work is how we operate. It’s anything but. LogoGarden was victimized and has taken steps to avoid a recurrence.

    For one thing, we discovered that the problem symbols came from a small handful of dishonest design brokers—after we had contracted and paid them for strictly original work. Going forward, we are sticking with designers and brokers who have proven themselves honest and reliable—as well as talented and accomplished. I think they do a terrific job for us.

    That’s not all. We’ve launched an internal review of the entire LogoGarden symbol library. It’s a huge job, a month’s work for our team. Already days into the process, we expect to be finished the third week of September.

    Either now or in the future, if you do spot something questionable, please alert me at John@LogoGarden.com. I will personally ensure we take immediate action.

    Thanks for your understanding. We may be competitors having very different business models, but we do share a goal with integrity: to offer clean, high quality design choices for people who need them.

    John Williams,
    President, LogoGarden.com

    Reply
  2. avant garde designer says

    August 29, 2011 at 6:43 pm

    This properly worded statement by Logo Garden seems to be appearing in quite a few blog comments! I guess it’s commendable that Logo Garden addresses this issue. But have you noticed just how carefully they’ve covered all their bases?

    Check out this article: http://bit.ly/nEPHQV

    According to that, Logo Garden’s Terms of Service completely removes them of any infringement responsibility. When people purchase any of its logos, they agree to assume all responsibility for actions taken against them for using that logo.

    Wow, how convenient is that? Logo Garden customers, you’d better beware.

    Reply
  3. Ann says

    September 26, 2011 at 1:33 pm

    OK, folks. If you think you’re getting a good bargain, know this: Someone else spent time and intelligence (that’s why they call this stuff intellectual property) designing these logos. Then this sleeze goes and lifts them for his own gain.

    High quality? Maybe yes. Clean? No way.

    Have some balls. Show integrity. Think enough of your business to hire a real designer, instead of supporting this ripoff company.

    Reply
  4. Tom White says

    October 7, 2011 at 10:49 pm

    You hit the nail on the head. What kind of person creates a business where the business model is selling other clients’ branding and intellectual property thereby setting each one of the discount logo buyers up for legal action against them? Forget his disclaimer, it’s just a really stupid business model. How can he guarantee satisfaction to a client who gets sued for using his services? Logo Garden users beware big time. If your company and what it stands for means something to you, best to hire a professional for all the reasons mentioned above in this article

    Reply
  5. adunate says

    October 8, 2011 at 7:29 am

    Tom, thanks for your comment. Business model, indeed. At the end of the day, how much pride does the LogoGarden “design” team feel for the work they do? How do they value themselves as people, knowing they lack integrity when doing business with others?

    Speaking of work…Tom, I checked your website. Your illustrative style is awesome! Continue on with your good work. Let’s together show what honest, quality and from-the-heart design really is!

    Reply
  6. glorielle says

    March 31, 2015 at 6:25 pm

    DO NOT USE!!!! LOGO GARDEN IS SO SHADY! THEY ATTEMPTED TO STEAL UNAUTHORIZED MONEY FROM MY ACCOUNT!!!!

    Reply
  7. Sharon Atlmeyer says

    May 14, 2015 at 8:35 am

    Are they even in business anymore? My website cannot be updated and I can no longer get my mail through them. Help!

    Reply
    • adunate says

      May 14, 2015 at 8:53 am

      Sharon, how frustrating. I clicked on their website and it’s still there as if they’re doing business. My blog certainly doesn’t have a million-hits-a-day readership, but even in its lowly state, according to my stats the post that’s most viewed is this one on Logo Garden. Maybe they’ve cleaned up their ethics from 2011, but do take caution nonetheless.

Love to hear from you! Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

CONNECT!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

CHECK OUT THE ARCHIVES

Categories

SUSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

What’s Instagramming

adunate

ah-du-NAH-tay [Latin: to unite] Uniting graphic design, copywriting & blessings of life. Sustainable ag, art, faith, food, nature & travel.

Instagram post 2193223300520190199_1477617082 Shared with permission, from Women in Ag. This is why I love doing business with these ladies! Read on...
.
YOU DON’T NEED TO SHOW YOUR ASS TO BE SEXY. ⁣
⁣Be a leader not a follower, show an example to our young girls  and boys .... they are our little legends running around ! How do  you want them to remember you ? .... be proud A woman of our great nation!! ❤️💯 I’m SO SICK and tired of girls being led to believe that they’ve got to pucker their lips, stick out their butt, flash some cleavage, and put seven filters on their face to feel like they’re cute. ⁣
⁣
Girls, this is sexy....⁣
⁣
Working hard. Physically, mentally, emotionally and spiritually.⁣
⁣
Giving of yourself. And even when you don’t feel like you can, having the faith to know that God will carry you through it.⁣
⁣
Making yourself a priority. Even if all that consists of is taking a 20 minute bath while Daddy watches the baby.⁣
⁣
Being a leader. Someone who lifts others up, encourages, and supports other women.⁣
⁣
Being a spouse who stands by their man. She fills the gap when he’s tired and weak, she is a soft place to fall and simultaneously hell on wheels when needed.⁣
⁣
It’s humility. Understanding that you’re one person in an enormous universe. The world doesn’t revolve around you.⁣
⁣
Being a life-long learner. You’re never going to be too smart to listen and learn something , even from the least expected places. Get off your pedestal, look around, and learn something. ⁣
⁣
It’s understanding your strength. Stop acting like a fragile little flower and woman up. Again, and again, and again.⁣
⁣
It’s being vulnerable. When “womaning-up” is just too hard, allowing yourself to accept your weaknesses and ask for help.⁣
⁣
These are just a taste of the qualities that can make up one helluva sexy woman. ⁣
⁣
Stop limiting yourself to six pack abs and booty bands.⁣
⁣
Pick up a freaking shovel, love someone, learn something, and discover yourself.⁣
⁣
That’s what sexy is to me.⁣
⁣
Which of these do you need to work on?⁣
⁣ ⁣
#⁣sexy #hardwork #getfit #wholeperson #gethealthy #livingyourbestlife #workingwoman #confidence #lifelonglearner #womeninbiz #womensupportingwomen #womenempoweringwomen #inspirational
Instagram post 2186127356595231504_1477617082 Cleansing flight before the storm.
.
#cleansingflight #beesinwinter #warmdaysinwinter
Instagram post 2175935114928477870_1477617082 #ninarose❤️
Follow on Instagram

What’s Tweetin’

My Tweets

CONNECT!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

GOOD FIT FOR YOUR PROJECT?

LET’S TALK!

Footer

CONNECT

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

OUR GUIDE

May the favor of the Lord our God rest on us; establish the work of our hands for us—yes, establish the work of our hands.

— Psalm 90:17

NEWS YOU CAN USE

  • ABOUT
  • SERVICES
  • PORTFOLIO
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Copyright © 2019 · Adunate Word & Design LLC · Watertown, Wisconsin · Privacy Policy