• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

  • ABOUT
  • SERVICES
    • COPY & FEATURE WRITING
    • DESIGN & BRANDING
    • ONLINE MARKETING
  • PORTFOLIO
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

How (Un)Ethical is Our Design?

July 6, 2010

Yesterday, my daughter and I discussed a recent New York Times article regarding criticism of an Obama cover photo.

The photo was used by the weekly news magazine The Economist for its June 19 issue. It shows Obama standing, head bowed, hands on hips, with an oil rig in the background. And he’s alone. It’s a dramatic shot evoking a strong message.

Turns out, in the original photo, Obama isn’t alone. Reuters photographer Larry Downing shot the image with two people standing alongside Obama, participating in an apparent conversation.

The Economist’s decision to digitally remove these two has caused a bit of ruckus. Some, including Reuters, feel altering the image has also altered the message.

My daughter’s and my discussion was interesting.

As a visual communications professional, I surmised the magazine wanted to convey a sense of isolation, that Obama is alone in his responsibility of the Gulf oil mess. The Economist’s editor claims not, but given the headline “Obama v. BP” and the story’s content, it’s hard to imagine otherwise. Whatever their motive, editing the extras from the photo creates a very striking composition.

My daughter viewed the issue from a journalistic side. As an attorney interested in government and current affairs, she felt altering the image was a misrepresentation of the event as it occurred. It did not convey the truth.

With today’s sophisticated editing software, this conflict of ethics becomes commonplace. We define graphic design as the use of words and images to visually communicate a message. Photojournalism, on the other hand, is the use of photography to tell a news story. The question we must then consider is how blurred can the line between the two become?

When does editing a photo become unethical?

Is editing software a threat to photojournalism?

Is a magazine cover a journalistic piece or an artistic piece?

How do photojournalism, advertising and art differ, and how should editing ethics apply to each?

What’s your opinion?

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: ethics, giving it some thought, graphic design, newspapers, photography, photojournalism, politics  
9 Comments

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. who cares says

    July 7, 2010 at 8:50 am

    I don’t see the big deal. What if the photographer had taken a picture of only Obama? How would that be different than cropping out the other people?

    Reply
  2. Terri says

    July 7, 2010 at 8:56 am

    Digital editing becomes a problem when you can no longer trust a photograph.

    Reply
  3. SL says

    July 7, 2010 at 9:07 am

    It is a big deal. Obama was meeting with a Coast Guard official and a local government official, not exactly brainless people in this situation. He wasn’t alone in his observation of the oil problem.

    A good photojournalist shoots an image that tells the complete story of what’s happening. Had he shot Obama by himself, he wouldn’t have told the whole story.

    Reply
  4. avant garde design says

    July 7, 2010 at 9:34 am

    Considering it’s the cover photo, there’s more to consider. The cover has to attract the viewer’s attention. Once it has that attention, the story can cover the details of the event.

    The edited photo is a much stronger than the original. Compositionally, it’s spot on. It puts the focus on Obama, and that’s what the story is about – how Obama is dealing with the Gulf oil crisis.

    Reply
  5. Jenny says

    July 7, 2010 at 9:07 pm

    I don’t think the fact that it’s a cover photo changes whether it’s misleading or not. Although I admittedly haven’t read the article, it seems like this cover is being used to portray the President being helpless and alone, whereas the original photo depicts something much different. I also think a news magazine (or photojournalism in general) has a different ethical obligation in terms of how it edits the photos, whether on the cover or in the article. A misleading headline wouldn’t (or at least shouldn’t) be excused simply because it’s on the cover and is used to grab the readers attention, neither should a photo.

    Reply
  6. Jason says

    July 7, 2010 at 11:08 pm

    This same thing came up a few weeks ago. Outside magazine photoshopped a slogan onto Lance Armstrong’s blank T-shirt. He was very upset. I’m sure Obama is too. I think all forms of photo manipulation are unethical in professional publications, if they skew the reality in any way.

    Reply
  7. adunate says

    July 8, 2010 at 8:21 am

    From a creative’s point of view, I’m wondering if The Economist sought permission to edit the photo? They obviously must have purchased rights to use it, but if Reuters has a “strict policy against modifying, removing, adding to or altering any of its photographs without first obtaining the permission,” seems like The Economist could be in trouble.

    However, the Reuters quote in the NYT doesn’t specifically say The Economist did NOT have their permission. If that’s the case, then Reuters is as much the dirty editor as The Economist, because they approved the alteration.

    Reply
  8. adunate says

    July 8, 2010 at 8:35 am

    Terri, your comment is so true. The problem is we, the viewers have no idea when we can or cannot trust a photograph. I think most of us have no clue how much editing goes into every photo before it’s printed.

    When I studied Photoshop we not only learned to remove blemishes, but to make people look younger, skinnier, healthier… Our assignments required us to completely dismantle an image and rebuild it in other ways. Last year, I toured Quad Graphics and talked with photo editors. That’s their only job, to prepare the photos used in a story. If they do this 8+ hours a day, imagine how expert they become.

    What I never knew until studying photography is that photo editing has been going on as long as there has been photography. Shooting the image is only half the skill of a photographer. The other half is in the dark room of the old days, or in Photoshop of nowadays.

    Reply
  9. adunate says

    July 8, 2010 at 8:55 am

    I like the comment someone made for the NYT’s article. He said editing the photo makes Obama look sad and dejected, like he doesn’t have the support of the American people. But if you look at the real photo, Obama’s head is down because he’s listening to people who happen to be shorter than he is. This makes him look caring, concerned and smart enough to seek advice from professionals.

    This person’s comment really emphasizes how the media shapes our opinions. They really are gatekeepers to events as they really happen.

    Reply

Love to hear from you! Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

CONNECT!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

CHECK OUT THE ARCHIVES

Categories

SUSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

What’s Instagramming

adunate

ah-du-NAH-tay [Latin: to unite] Uniting graphic design, copywriting & blessings of life. Sustainable ag, art, faith, food, nature & travel.

Instagram post 2193223300520190199_1477617082 Shared with permission, from Women in Ag. This is why I love doing business with these ladies! Read on...
.
YOU DON’T NEED TO SHOW YOUR ASS TO BE SEXY. ⁣
⁣Be a leader not a follower, show an example to our young girls  and boys .... they are our little legends running around ! How do  you want them to remember you ? .... be proud A woman of our great nation!! ❤️💯 I’m SO SICK and tired of girls being led to believe that they’ve got to pucker their lips, stick out their butt, flash some cleavage, and put seven filters on their face to feel like they’re cute. ⁣
⁣
Girls, this is sexy....⁣
⁣
Working hard. Physically, mentally, emotionally and spiritually.⁣
⁣
Giving of yourself. And even when you don’t feel like you can, having the faith to know that God will carry you through it.⁣
⁣
Making yourself a priority. Even if all that consists of is taking a 20 minute bath while Daddy watches the baby.⁣
⁣
Being a leader. Someone who lifts others up, encourages, and supports other women.⁣
⁣
Being a spouse who stands by their man. She fills the gap when he’s tired and weak, she is a soft place to fall and simultaneously hell on wheels when needed.⁣
⁣
It’s humility. Understanding that you’re one person in an enormous universe. The world doesn’t revolve around you.⁣
⁣
Being a life-long learner. You’re never going to be too smart to listen and learn something , even from the least expected places. Get off your pedestal, look around, and learn something. ⁣
⁣
It’s understanding your strength. Stop acting like a fragile little flower and woman up. Again, and again, and again.⁣
⁣
It’s being vulnerable. When “womaning-up” is just too hard, allowing yourself to accept your weaknesses and ask for help.⁣
⁣
These are just a taste of the qualities that can make up one helluva sexy woman. ⁣
⁣
Stop limiting yourself to six pack abs and booty bands.⁣
⁣
Pick up a freaking shovel, love someone, learn something, and discover yourself.⁣
⁣
That’s what sexy is to me.⁣
⁣
Which of these do you need to work on?⁣
⁣ ⁣
#⁣sexy #hardwork #getfit #wholeperson #gethealthy #livingyourbestlife #workingwoman #confidence #lifelonglearner #womeninbiz #womensupportingwomen #womenempoweringwomen #inspirational
Instagram post 2186127356595231504_1477617082 Cleansing flight before the storm.
.
#cleansingflight #beesinwinter #warmdaysinwinter
Instagram post 2175935114928477870_1477617082 #ninarose❤️
Follow on Instagram

What’s Tweetin’

My Tweets

CONNECT!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

GOOD FIT FOR YOUR PROJECT?

LET’S TALK!

Footer

CONNECT

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

OUR GUIDE

May the favor of the Lord our God rest on us; establish the work of our hands for us—yes, establish the work of our hands.

— Psalm 90:17

NEWS YOU CAN USE

  • ABOUT
  • SERVICES
  • PORTFOLIO
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Copyright © 2019 · Adunate Word & Design LLC · Watertown, Wisconsin · Privacy Policy